You've come to an old part of SW Online. We're still moving this and other older stories into our new format. In the meanwhile, click here to go to the current home page.
They want to scapegoat students for opposing war
Defend activists at SFSU

June 24, 2005 | Page 12

ON MARCH 9, Students Against War (SAW) at San Francisco State University (SFSU), a chapter of the Campus Antiwar Network, along with other student groups, organized a demonstration against military recruiters on our campus.

Two hundred students rallied in Malcolm X Plaza and then marched inside the Cesar Chavez Student Center to confront Army and Air Force recruiters. For over three hours, students chanted down the recruiters and then surrounded them with a peaceful teach-in.

The students protested the deaths of American soldiers, the brutal murder of Iraqi civilians and the military's bigoted "don't ask don't tell" policy, which is in blatant violation of the university's own ant-discrimination policies. The Army recruiters left within 45 minutes. The Air Force recruiters held out longer, but ultimately gave up and left--without any new recruits.

San Francisco State is part of a burgeoning national counter recruitment movement. From Seattle to New York, students have challenged the presence of military recruiters on their campuses.

This is coming at a time when the military is struggling to find new recruits. The Army has missed its recruiting goals for three straight months, falling short by 42 percent in April. The Marine Corps missed its goal for signing up new recruits for four straight months.

At the same time, the recruiters' lies and unethical conduct are being exposed. In nationally publicized cases, recruiters have knowingly signed people up with debilitating psychological disorders and told potential recruits that failure to keep appointments will result in a warrant being issued for their arrest. These incidents forced the Pentagon to suspend recruitment on May 30 in order to do special training and emphasize the need for ethical behavior.

Instead of defending its own anti-discrimination policy and the right of students to protest, however, SFSU decided to launch an attack against political activists on campus.

A day after students kicked military recruiters off campus, they returned to SFSU. When two activists attempted to hand out anti-recruitment leaflets by the recruiters' tables, eight police officers surrounded them and forcibly removed them from their own student center, pushing them and twisting one activist's arm. When the other activist asked why she was being forced to leave, she was pushed into a doorway, told she was causing a fire hazard by standing there, and then kicked out of the building.

Then, on March 18, 2005, three student activists, Katrina Yeaw, Michael Hoffman and Pardis Esmaeili, received letters stating that the administration has received a complaint from the Chief of Public Safety, and that each student must meet individually with Judicial Affairs. The following week, the six student organizations that endorsed the March 9 demonstration received letters stating that disciplinary proceedings were going forward against them.

The charges against four of the groups were eventually dropped, but the university went forward with a hearing against the International Socialist Organization (ISO) and SAW. On May 22, 2005, both groups were informed that they had been convicted of all charges against them in absentia.

The university sanctioned the groups, with both the ISO and SAW losing their funding for the 2005-2006 academic year. The leadership of the ISO is being forced to go through training on the university's demonstration guidelines and procedures before it can have any more events. Furthermore, if either organization violates either of these sanctions or any more university policies, the groups will be suspended for a period of one year.

The National Lawyers Guild (NLG), which represents the groups and individual activists involved, has denounced the university's decision to convict them in absentia. "San Francisco State ignored communications from NLG attorneys representing these student groups, and then held a hearing that denied students a proper opportunity to present their case," said NLG attorney Mark Vermeulen. "The process did not meet basic due process requirements and was completely unprofessional."

On the same day, the three individuals received a final notice that they must appear before Judicial Affairs. Failure to do so could compromise their student status and access to financial aid. The NLG is currently attempting to get a joint hearing for the three students.

It is absolutely ridiculous that the university is trying to sanction students and organizations on the grounds that they violated university procedures, considering that the university ignored its own anti-discrimination policy by allowing the presence of military recruiters on campus and denied students the due process they are allotted under university guidelines.

Furthermore, let's be honest about who is actually guilty of "breaking the rules." The Bush administration conducted a war and invasion based on lies. They have occupied another sovereign nation, and killed 1,700 Americans and more than 100,000 Iraqis--all in violation of international law and all for its own imperialist aims.

The attack on the counter-recruitment movement at San Francisco State is not an isolated incident. A similar protest at City College of New York on the same day resulted in activists being brutalized and arrested by campus security guards. The activists were charged with misdemeanor counts of assaulting an officer--though it was two protesters who suffered multiple contusions and post-concussion syndrome. All of the charges have since been dropped since they were completely baseless.

At the University of California-Santa Cruz, anti-war activists faced more police brutality. A week after a successful counter-recruitment demonstration, in which students were able to force their administration to ask Marine Corps recruiters to leave a career fair, student activists at a "Tent University" were attacked by the police. Tent University was a weeklong encampment to support the full funding of higher education and oppose the Iraq war. As students peacefully set up tents on their own campus for the night, police rioted, violently dispersing several hundred campers, arresting nearly 20 and injuring dozens.

We cannot let the scapegoating of activists be used to try to silence the counter-recruitment and antiwar movements.

There is a growing level of discontent and anger about the bloody occupation of Iraq that cannot be stifled by police brutality or a university administration. We need to build a vibrant counter-recruitment movement on every campus in the country to challenge the bigoted and brutal policies of the U.S. military. The defense of activists at San Francisco State University is an important part of that fight.
Katrina Yeaw and Alex Schmaus, San Francisco

To find out what you can do to help, e-mail [email protected] or go to CAN's Web site at

Home page | Back to the top