You've come to an old part of SW Online. We're still moving this and other older stories into our new format. In the meanwhile, click here to go to the current home page.
Another innocent man freed from prison in New York state
"The wheels of justice are flat"

By Dylan Stillwood | February 2, 2007 | Page 2

ROY BROWN spent 15 years in prison for a murder he didn't commit, but on January 23, he finally walked free after DNA evidence proved he was innocent.

Facing reporters, Brown placed the blame on the whole criminal justice system. "Changes have got to be made, man," he said. "They say the wheels of justice move slowly, but you know what? The wheels of justice are flat."

Brown is the eighth person in New York state to be exonerated by DNA evidence in the last 13 months. At least half of these cases involved misconduct by police or prosecutors.

Brown's case is a stark example. The only witness against him was a jailhouse informant, and the only physical evidence were bite marks on the victim's body. Before the trial, one of the country's leading experts said the bite marks excluded Brown, who was missing two front teeth, as a suspect.

What you can do

Join activists for a panel discussion on the New York injustice system's shameful record. On February 6, at 7 p.m., at the National Black Theater, 2031 5th Ave. (at 125th Street).


But instead of releasing him, prosecutors got a local dentist to give different testimony against Brown. Jurors were never told that bite-mark evidence has a 63 percent rate of false identification.

After a decade in prison, Brown solved the case by himself while behind bars. He ordered all the police statements in the case, many of which his lawyer had never seen. The police had received a tip about another suspect, Barry Bench, but never pursued him--possibly because he was friends with the prosecutor.

With this new evidence, and the help of the New York-based Innocence Project, Brown ordered the DNA tests that finally cleared his name.

Roy Brown's nightmare is all too common in New York state. The latest exonerations of the wrongfully convicted reveal a history of forced confessions, junk science, rigged juries and suppressed evidence. But while other states have launched commissions to investigate such allegations, New York refuses to admit there's a problem.

On February 6, the Campaign to End the Death Penalty and New Yorkers Against the Death Penalty will host a panel discussion to expose New York's shameful epidemic of wrongful convictions.

Four exonerees will speak--Alan Newton and Jeff Deskovic, who spent half their lives in prison for crimes they didn't commit; Yusef Salaam, who was railroaded in the Central Park jogger case; and Lawrence Hayes, a former Black Panther framed for killing a police officer. They will talk about their experiences, and encourage more people to join the fight against the death penalty and the criminal injustice system.

Home page | Back to the top