Sanctions that defy sanity

September 22, 2010

Israel's punishing sanctions against the people of Gaza demand a response.

IF I were a college student, I would grab some friends and a card table, and make a beeline for the busiest spot on campus to set up shop. On the table, I'd place a chicken breast, a two-by-four and a kazoo, and hang a sign reading: "How do you make a bomb with these?"

Fresh meat, wood and kazoos are among the dozens of items banned in Gaza by the Israeli state under the pretext that weapons could be made of them to attack Israelis. To be fair, kazoos are not specifically mentioned--though fresh meat and wood for construction are--but all musical instruments are banned from the Strip, and I figure even a strapped American student can purchase a kazoo from a 99-cent store.

In fact, in the Kafkaesque world of Israeli state sanctions on Gaza, no actual list is published, and the banned items must be deduced from the day-to-day practices of the authorities. An up-to-date list is maintained at the Web site Gisha.org.

This week marks exactly three years since Gaza--the open-air prison camp of 1.5 million--was named an "enemy entity" by its warden, the Israeli state. While the policies that have isolated and stranded Gazans in a Mediterranean hell began in 1991, they have intensified since Hamas took control in 2007 following elections that all international observers agree were democratically run.

Wrap your brain around that for a moment. Nineteen-year-old Gazans--the age of many college sophomores--have only known stultifying restrictions on their movements inside the territory. A generation was born and has now reached maturity, never having traveled even as far as the 48 miles between Gaza City and Jerusalem.

An essay by Harvard scholar Sara Roy in the newly released Midnight on the Mavi Marmara reveals the outcome of Israel's blockade. Seventy-five percent of the population is dependent on humanitarian aid, chronic malnourishment is rampant, and 90–95 percent of all water is "unfit for drinking," Roy reports.

Regarding the sewage-steeped water, the United Nations' Goldstone Report declares, "Gaza may not even be habitable by World Health Organization norms."


IN ATTEMPTING to render Hamas a pariah leadership to Gazans, Israel has not only created a humanitarian catastrophe, but actually strengthened the hand of its stated enemy. The formal banking sector obliterated, Hamas stands as "the key financial middleman," according to Roy.

In Mavi Marmara, Israeli journalist Amira Hass adds that the rule of Hamas only grows stronger as the desperation serves to concentrate their power, if not their popularity.

Israeli state propagandists would like everyone to believe that even Jews in solidarity with Palestine are secretly in cahoots with Hamas. They talk as if secular reds like me, raised on Bar Mitzvahs and basketball, want to drive Jews into the sea. What? Why would I want to push my parents into the East River? Or the Mediterranean?!

Listen. We on the left are accustomed to taking on Sisyphean tasks like ending imperialism or stopping global warming. This is not one of them. Ending the siege of Gaza--breaking the blockade--and establishing basic human norms for Palestinians is within our reach.

Last week, even the British Trades Union Council voted to extend its boycott of Israeli goods in solidarity with their brothers and sisters in Palestine. Ever since the killing of nine humanitarian aid activists on the Mavi Marmara aid flotilla ship on May 31, 2010, the movement has expanded to include European governments and students worldwide.

We must act with clarity of vision and urgency to expose Israel's crimes and build the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement. You can even start with a card table and a kazoo.

First published at sherrytalksback.

Further Reading

From the archives