Burying treasure in their tax havens

November 14, 2017

In an article written for Australia's Red Flag newspaper, Tom Bramble describes the revelations of the Paradise Papers that show how the rich scam the rest of us.

HARD ON the heels of last year's Panama Papers leak, which exposed massive tax evasion by the world's fat cats, a new mass leak of documents, named the Paradise Papers, has confirmed that the flagrant looting of national treasuries by the world's 1 Percent continues unabated.

The leak of more than 13 million files from two offshore service providers and the company registries of 19 tax havens reveals widespread scheming to hide money. The offenders include the Queen of England, whose private estate has invested millions of pounds in the Cayman Islands; Donald Trump's Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, who has murky dealings with Russian businessmen; Twitter and Facebook, linked with Russian state banks; and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's financier who funded his rise to power and has millions of dollars stashed away in the Cayman Islands.

The Paradise Papers also report that the British Conservative Party's biggest donor, Lord Ashcroft, has squirreled away nearly half a billion dollars in an offshore trust, while Nike and Apple continue to avoid or evade tax to the tune of billions of dollars.

Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross outside the White House
Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross outside the White House (Evan Walker | flickr)

The giant leak also unearths examples of deep-seated corporate crookery. These include mining giant Glencore's secret deals to secure lucrative mining rights in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

And if all that werne't enough, the mega-rich score billions of dollars in tax refunds in the Isle of Man and Malta when they buy private jets and luxury yachts.

The total sums involved are staggering. The Tax Justice Network reports global annual tax losses--money that should have been paid to tax offices--of $500 billion or more, representing more than 20 percent of corporate revenues.

Tax evasion has deadly consequences. The money has been robbed from essential services. Every dollar secreted in offshore tax havens is a dollar less for health, education and social welfare spent at home.

GOVERNMENTS ARE complicit in this theft because they have drafted tax codes that make it all possible. The tax evasion industry claims, with some basis, that its activities are entirely legal. Far from lurking in the shadows, the industry proudly boasts its credentials. It is populated by the bluest of blue chips--companies proudly boasting their trade with fine brass plates on the doors of their head offices, secure knowing that they and their clients will remain untouched by the courts.

And when those who advise the wealthy how to hide their money do cross the line, governments simply look the other way. Despite the enormous resources of tax offices around the world, staffed by teams of crack investigative staff armed with legal powers to inspect company books, it has been committed journalists, not the tax inspectors, who have lifted the lid on these scams.

The succession of leaks and public exposés published by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists in recent years has pressured governments to pass legislation to limit tax evasion by multinational companies, including here in Australia in 2015.

But such laws have been weak and ineffective, in part thanks to sustained lobbying by the tax evasion industry. As the case of billionaire and U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross illustrates, those who should be acting to safeguard the public interest are sometimes direct beneficiaries of the status quo.

The real response of most governments is revealed by their determination not to send corporate crooks to jail, but to cut company and personal income tax. Governments boast about how low they have pushed tax rates to lure the wealthy to park their money in their countries.

In 2016, the Irish government protested strenuously against a decision by the European Commission to force Apple to pay the government $15 billion in back taxes. Even now, the U.S. Congress is debating Donald Trump's plans to slash taxes, which would redistribute money massively to the already well off.

In Australia, the government has reduced staff in departments investigating tax evasion, making it even less likely that malfeasance will be unearthed. The whole system is stacked in favor of the rich; the politicians and the fat cats scratch each other's backs.

Despite some huffing and puffing by governments about promoting global tax transparency, tax evasion is booming. A recent study found that 5-10 percent of the profits of U.S. multinationals was shifted offshore for tax purposes in the 1990s. It now stands at 25 percent or more. By the very nature of the phenomenon, it is impossible to get a definite fix on the sums involved, but estimates of undeclared offshore wealth range from $8 trillion to $30 trillion, vast sums in anyone's books.

THE HYPOCRISY of it all is stunning. Most of us don't get to avoid paying taxes--our employers take it out of our pay before we even see it. But for the rich, an army of advisers is standing by ready to help. As British Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn pointed out in parliament, "There's one rule for the super-rich and another for the rest when it comes to paying tax."

For years, governments have been doling out the thin gruel of austerity. They say that "we're all in this together" as they cut public services and the jobs, wages and pensions of millions of public sector workers. But the Paradise Papers illustrate that this is all just a cruel hoax.

Instead of sending inspectors to the fancy offices and posh private clubs in Wall Street, Pall Mall or Martin Place to root out those owing the government millions of dollars in unpaid tax, money that could fund vital services, governments have recruited armies of inspectors to harass welfare recipients and the unemployed, accompanied by frenzied media commentary about lazy poor people and welfare scams and scare campaigns about immigrants or refugees "ripping us off."

First published at Red Flag.

Further Reading

From the archives