Subject: [SocialistWorker.org] A tale of two cities
-----
View original article here:
http://socialistworker.org/2009/07/06/tale-of-two-cities
Comment: Leela Yellesetty
======== A TALE OF TWO CITIES ================================================
Two Americas exist side by side--one where a tiny minority of the rich enjoys
immense wealth, and another where the vast majority barely scrapes by, and
sometimes not even that. Leela Yellesetty describes the yawning gap between
rich and poor in Seattle.
July 6, 2009 | Issue 700
IT IS a typical gray day in Seattle, but the view of the city from Capitol
Hill is still impressive. On nicer days, the Olympic Mountains provide a
stunning backdrop to the city's signature landmark, the Space Needle. To the
south, on the edge of the city skyline, luxury condominiums crop up like
weeds in various stages of construction.
I'm standing in the parking lot of St. Marks Episcopal Church, talking with
Charles "Mac" McGlinghey, who has been kind enough to show me his home.
"Go ahead and poke your head in and look around," he says. I peer inside, but
it is too small to enter. Taking up most of the space is a makeshift bed
constructed from crates, with a layer of blankets on top to protect Mac and
his wife from sleeping on the cold concrete of the church lot. The rest of
their things easily fill the small space on the other side of the two-person
tent. "That's pretty much everything we own aside from what we have in a
small storage space down in Kent," he says.
With his big bushy beard making him look uncannily like Santa Claus, Mac sits
calmly atop a crate outside, and points with his cane two tents down. "That's
where my son lives," he says.
Mac's stepson was abused so badly by his biological father that, at age 31,
he only has the mental maturity of a 10-year-old. The three of them have
lived in Tent City III, a self-governed community of about 100 homeless
people, for the past three months.
"We're here because we can't get an apartment," says Mac. "Every time we
apply for one, they say you need to make three times the amount of rent in
income. Well, that's all well and good if I could work and had a job. But
where am I going to find a place for $210 a month? For three people?
Considering all three of us collect SSI, and I collect Social Security
disability, that's what it comes down to. There's no way you can get a place
on that."
Mac has been on the list for Section 8 affordable housing for the past eight
months and hopes it comes through soon.
But Nick, another man I meet at the camp, tells me he's been on the list for
two years. He's been homeless since a debilitating accident on the job cut
off his livelihood as a carpenter three years ago. Soft-spoken and shy about
sharing his opinion, Nick says simply, "We need more housing. You can't just
get rid of the homeless. You can't have rich people without poor people."
Life-changing accidents seem to be a common theme among the stories at Tent
City. Mac has a dissociative disorder that has prevented him from holding a
job for the past 30 years. He traces its origins to an accident when he was
in the Navy, decommissioning a ship after two tours in Vietnam.
"Something fell off the pallet, while I was down in the hole," he says. "It
wasn't up too high, but it fell about 10 feet and hit me in the head. I was
unconscious for about 15 seconds, and ever since that time, I've had the
problem. The Navy never 'fessed up to it. They've acknowledged the fact that
something happened, but they don't know what. And it's not their fault.
That's typical of the military, though."
I ask Mac how many of the residents here are veterans. "Alright, let's start
with the people out here," he says, and points to five people among the 20 or
so who are milling about the center of camp. He estimates that at least 20
percent are vets overall.
"We had one gentlemen here for awhile who just got back from Iraq," he says.
"You got people like me from Vietnam, and just about everyone else in
between. We all have our horror stories to tell. Most of the vets, because of
our experience, kind of look out for everyone else and keep the peace. Bottom
line, we're tired of fighting. But every day here is a fight."
I came here to investigate the growth of tent cities as a result of the
current economic crisis. Stories on this topic have made headlines across the
country, for the first time perhaps since the Great Depression of the 1930s.
But what strikes me as I'm here is that there's nothing new about these
symbols of dire poverty in the world's richest nation. Tent City I was formed
back in 1991. Many of the residents of the three tent cities in the Seattle
area have been homeless for years. As Ben Ehrenreich pointed out in the
/Nation/ magazine:
>While recent media accounts portrayed Tent City's incarnations as creatures
>of the recession--reborn Hoovervilles for the laid off and the
>foreclosed--shantytowns have been a periodic but permanent feature of
>American urban life for at least the past two decades...Tent City tells the
>grueling back story to the current recession--nearly 30 years of cuts in
>social services to the poor and mentally ill, the decimation of the
>industrial economy and the cruel underside of the housing boom.
>
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
AS MUCH as Seattle's homeless are struggling in these tough economic times,
they aren't the only ones with problems--at least according to Seattle
entrepreneur Andy Sack, who recently announced he's starting up a support
group for another group in need: multimillionaires.
Seattle is now home to the newest chapter of Tiger 21, an exclusive New
York-based network of clubs for the exceedingly wealthy. To join Tiger 21,
you have to have at least $10 million in assets, not including houses, cars
and other properties, and pay a $30,000-a-year membership fee. Nationwide,
Tiger 21 has about 170 members with an average net worth between $30 million
and $50 million.
Home to executives at Microsoft, Boeing, Starbucks and Amazon, not to mention
a host of dot-com millionaires like Sack, Seattle should have no trouble
attracting members. In fact, it's surprising the city didn't already have a
club where the super-rich could help each other endure their predicament.
What predicament? Tiger 21 Managing Director Lewis Haskell says that finding
people to relate to can be difficult for the superrich. "People are either
jealous or they can't understand you have problems," Haskell says. "They say,
'I should have such problems,' or 'How hard can it be?'"
As an article about the group in the Seattle-based /Xconomy/ puts it:
>Think the super-rich don't have problems? Try fending off friends and
>relatives who always want to borrow money, or raising spoiled brats who
>don't take responsibility for their actions. Not to mention the more obvious
>financial questions of how to manage such hefty portfolios--especially in
>economic times like these. (Granted, some of this might be viewed as
>insensitive at a time when local food banks are running out of food.)
>
Sack, who made his fortune investing in Web startups, writes a blog
discussing the trials and tribulations of being rich, and dropping pearls of
wisdom for those who aspire to his level of greatness. Among his many astute
observations: "In the game of business, success is measured by dollars. It
makes sense that people are motivated by selfishness and 'greed' and the
general desire to improve one's financial standing. This isn't a bad
thing--it's what capitalism is based upon."
Yet in a later post, Sack reflects,
>It's not about the money. So much of success in America is driven and
>measured by money. Money is not and should not be the measure of success--or
>happiness. One of the best conversations I had this weekend was with someone
>who has been unemployed for two years, and spent nine months meditating. He
>quit his 90K per year job to elect for unemployment because he felt the job
>was killing the life in him. Pretty fascinating guy. He was amongst the
>happiest--if not the "wealthiest" people I met.
>
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
TO INVESTIGATE whether the unemployed are truly the happiest people around, I
made a trip down to Qwest Field, a taxpayer-subsidized stadium controlled by
another Seattle titan, Paul Allen. It also happens to be the location of
Jobbernaut.com's Greater Seattle Job Fair, held every three months.
"You should have been here in February," says Jobbernaut promoter Troy
Kleine. "Because of all the layoffs from the holidays, there was a line going
all the way around the building. It made the front page of the paper." Kleine
said the number who attended in February--7,326--was nearly double that of
October. He wasn't sure exactly why the totals were lower this time around,
but guessed that some people had simply given up.
"I've been looking for work for about two-and-a-half months, and there's
nothing, nothing at all," said job fair attendee Autumn Walker. "If you don't
have any education, like a BA, there's no way to get a job. I've been looking
everywhere. I've been on Monster.com, Craigslist, NW Jobs. I'm a chef by
trade. I cook, but I don't do fast food. I'm not working at McDonalds."
I told her that another person I spoke to said even McDonalds wasn't hiring,
and she shook her head. "It's hard looking for a job right about now," she
said. "Our economy's shot. I just think everyone has to sit back and wait for
Obama to work his magic, because Bush messed up. I know he's not going to be
able to make it happen overnight for the whole country--but at least a few
more jobs out here for a few more people."
Most people I spoke to were still optimistic about being able to find work
eventually, and had faith that Obama would turn the economy around. Being a
temporary employee facing unemployment myself in a few months' time, I want
to believe it, too.
But the recent statistics are not uplifting. Official unemployment in
Washington state (not counting those who are underemployed or have simply
given up looking) now stands at 9 percent, up from 4.7 percent last year. A
recent report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics found that there are an
average of five job seekers for every available opening nationally. And so
far this year, more than a million homes have gone into foreclosure--or about
one every 13 seconds.
While the homeless have long existed in Seattle, their ranks are
increasing--a trend that will likely accelerate in the months to come. The
Seattle/King County Coalition on Homelessness' One Night Count of January
2008 found 8,439 people homeless countywide. Just over 5,800 had shelter
through existing programs, but more than 2,600 were without--a 15 percent
increase over last year.
Use of food banks and soup kitchens are also on the rise across the region.
Seattle's Cherry Street Food Bank recently saw 2,651 people walk through
their doors in a single day--an all-time record.
Back at Tent City, Adam Jama is one of the newest residents. He was laid off
from his job as an airport shuttle bus driver back in September, but only
recently learned that he could have applied for unemployment benefits.
An immigrant, he also found out that in order to get another job, he must pay
$340 to renew his work permit. Like most of the newly homeless, Adam first
stayed with family and friends until he began to wear out his welcome. He
heard about Tent City III from a man on the bus a couple weeks ago. "It's
better than staying on the streets," he says. "They don't turn people away,
if there's space available."
There are only 100 slots available at Tent City III. Once you're in, you can
stay as long as you abide by the rules. If people turn up and there is no
space, they are allowed to stay one night, but can't come back again for a
week. Adam tells me at least five people come through every night.
Of those fortunate enough to find a place to stay, many prefer places like
Tent City III because unlike the shelters, the tent cities are democratically
run by residents. Couples are allowed to stay together, which is almost
always denied in shelters. They also allow for people to leave their things
in a safe place, rather than being kicked out with all their belongings each
morning.
This is even more important now since one of the few buildings open to the
homeless during the day--the public library--recently passed new rules
restricting large bags. The tent cities offer a small measure of community
and dignity in the face of the daily humiliations of surviving without a
home.
Nonetheless, anyone here can tell you that living in a tent is no picnic. And
as if life weren't hard enough, the city of Seattle, far from offering
assistance, is hell-bent on shutting down the tent cities.
The latest example: A group called Seattle Housing and Resource Effort
(SHARE) provides shelter and other services for the homeless, including two
free bus tickets per day. This is a lifeline for Tent City residents,
especially those who have jobs or are looking for one.
But the city is cutting off funding for the tickets, so SHARE will run out of
money for the program by around the July 4 weekend. The organization is
planning a direct action to protest--the homeless will head to the homes of
the city's political leaders (first stop: Mayor Greg Nichols) and sleep on
the sidewalk outside.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
TREATING THOSE who can't afford a place to live as an eyesore at best and a
criminal element at worst is a time-honored tradition in Seattle.
In the 1930s, a massive Hooverville spang up south of the city, where Qwest
Field sits today, swelling to a population of over 1,200 at its peak. The
city burned it to the ground.
When Tent City II was founded back in 1998, the city council invited
residents to meet and discuss more permanent options. While the residents
were at the meeting, the city bulldozed their encampment.
Through a series of legal appeals, Tent City III finally reached an agreement
with the city to camp legally on private land, but the catch is they can only
stay at one location a few months at a time. The camp has moved more than 50
times since 2000.
Nickelsville, a more recently formed tent city named after Mayor Nickels
because of his cruel homeless sweeps, took a more aggressive approach by
initially setting up on city property. Residents were forcibly evicted by the
police after four days. Twenty-two people were arrested when they refused to
move.
After a few other temporary locations, Nickelsville recently made what
residents and supporters hope will be its last move, to a parcel adjacent to
the city land it occupied last September. Residents and organizers said that
because they are on state land, Gov. Christine Gregoire can trump the mayor
and let them stay. "I will be arrested if I have to," Nickelsville resident
Bruce Beaver told King 5 News, "We need places to stay and shelters don't
always cut it."
At the University of Washington, a public health class is taking on a
campaign to bring Tent City III to campus. At a campus forum on the topic,
former tent city resident and homeless advocate Anitra Freeman pointed out
that 330 people have died from being out on the streets in Seattle since
2000--50 just in the last year. As Freeman said:
>The life expectancy during the Black Death was better than for homeless
>people today. That is unconscionable to me...People deserve better than
>tents, but they deserve /at least/ tents--they die without them. Democracy
>is predicated on the assumption that we are all of equal value. If we are
>letting people die on our streets, then we have no respect for humanity in
>this country, and we're in serious trouble.
>
At the forum, I recognized James Wlos, who I'd met over a year ago tabling at
the International Longshore and Warehouse Union hiring hall. Wlos had been
picking up hours as a casual at the Port of Seattle, but right now, there's
no work, and he's living out of his car. He waved a stack of parking tickets
in the air, explaining that you can't park your car anywhere through the
night in the city without getting them.
"I can't even afford to be homeless," Wlos says. "All these corporations are
taking money from me they don't even need. It doesn't have to be like this.
If we work together, we can hire people to grow food, to build solar
generators, whatever. Imagine the possibilities. Obama won't do it for us--we
have to do it ourselves."
The solutions to the housing crisis should be obvious to anyone who thinks
about it. When newly constructed luxury condos are standing empty all around,
there's no reason people should have to live in tents, much less in cars or
on the streets.
Instead, the people who were neglected in good times are expected to suffer
even worse when times get tough. As the crisis deepens, more and more people
are at risk of becoming economic casualties.
On the chopping block in this year's budget are funds for virtually every
social service in the city, from mental health care to public transportation.
Five public schools are slated for closure, and 173 teachers just received
pink slips. The only budget item that remains untouched is for a new city
jail, at a cost of $200 million.
I guess this is the politicians' idea of a public housing program.
Meanwhile, in the other Seattle, the wealthy cope with the terrible burden of
having more money than they know what to do with.
I have some ideas. The Economic Opportunity Institute estimates that a 3
percent surtax on incomes between $200,000 and $999,999 and a 5 percent
surtax on incomes over $1 million in Washington state could raise $2.6
billion immediately--more than enough to stop the proposed cuts to public
health, the General Assistance-Unemployable program, and basic education, and
provide more relief to those who need it most.
Washington state has one of the most regressive tax structures in the
country--meaning that the wealthy pay proportionally less of their incomes in
taxes. According to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, the
poorest 20 percent of Washingtonians pay 17.5 percent of their income in
taxes each year, while the top 1 percent pay just 3.3 percent.
Recent polls indicate a majority of people support making the wealthy pay
their fair share in taxes. Yet the Democratic-controlled legislature and
governor refuse to countenance the idea.
Many people in Seattle are beginning to conclude that we need to take our
city back--from the Nickelsville residents holding their ground, to the
students organizing against budget cuts, to teachers' union members
protesting layoffs.
The Andy Sacks of the world may think their lives are tough, but here's
hoping things get a lot harder for them--when the rest of us stand up to
demand our fair share.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
What you can do
The future of the Nickelsville tent city depends on convincing Gov. Gregoire
that the homeless shouldn't be evicted from state land. Tell her today your
opinion of Nickelsville--call 800-562-6000, fax 360-753-4110 or e-mail
govcommoffice@gov.wa.gov [1]. You can also sign a petition [2] calling on the
governor to let Nickelsville be left in peace.
Residents of Nickelsville are always in need of water, 2-by-4s nails,
non-perishable foods and friendly faces. You can find them at West Marginal
Way SW & 2nd Avenue SW.
The organization Seattle and Housing Resource Effort (SHARE) is appealing for
funds to help maintain its program of giving free city bus tickets to the
homeless. You can send a check or money order payable to: SHARE, 1902 2nd
Ave., Seattle, WA 98101. You can contact SHARE at 206-448-7889
If you'd like to express your displeasure with Seattle Mayor Greg Nichols for
cutting off city funds to SHARE, call 206-684-4000.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Published by the International Socialist Organization. Material on this Web
site is licensed by SocialistWorker.org, under a Creative Commons (by-nc-nd
3.0) license, except for articles that are republished with permission.
Readers are welcome to share and use material belonging to this site for
non-commercial purposes, as long as they are attributed to the author and
SocialistWorker.org.
[1] mailto:govcommoffice@gov.wa.gov
[2] http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/let-the-nickelodeons-live-in-peace
